Identifying the Most Probable Cost – Schedule Values from a Joint Confidence Level (JCL) Analysis

This course on project controls is brought to you by GBRI's partnership with Project Controls Expo. Click here to learn more
PCE-Virtual-logo
David Hulett
Samuel Steiman
· Published on:August 6, 2021

Integrated cost-schedule risk analysis allows calculation of Joint Confidence Level, the probability that both cost and schedule targets will simultaneously be met. Organizations such as NASA require JCL-70 for major new projects. For most projects where cost and schedule results are not highly correlated, a family of constant JCL-70 outcomes results in a “necklace” of points from which the analyst must select recommended cost/schedule target values. How should the analyst select defendable targets for presentation to management? This is not a matter of choosing the combination of cost and finish date most pleasing to the performer or the customer, but of choosing the combination that meets the JCL-70 (or whatever level of confidence in the estimate is needed) that is the most likely to occur with the scenario (e.g., pre-mitigation) being considered.

Some “eye-ball” a selected JCL-70 point, approximating the densest point in the scatter plot, but that is not convincing for budgetary purposes. Others draw the regression line through the scatterplot and pick the intersection with the JCL-70 necklace, but linear regression, by answering the best linear fit of the dataset, answers a completely different statistical question and is not necessarily reliable as a measure of the most likely combination of the JCL-70 cost and schedule.

This paper describes innovative graphical methods using three-dimensional histograms and surface plots of the scatter data to identify the most likely cost/schedule values at any JCL. The methods are demonstrated using actual scatter data from four real projects. The results validate the methodology as a sound basis for selecting cost/schedule targets and demonstrate how the regression line intersect becomes unreliable as cost/schedule correlation decrease.

David Hulett

President for Hulett & Associates, LLC Michael Trumper - Partner for Intaver Institute Inc.

    Samuel Steiman

    Director, Power Services for MPR Associates, Inc.

      About Instructor

      Emil

      144 Courses

      Not Enrolled

      Course Includes

      • 1 Lesson

      Responses

      Your email address will not be published.

      The journey to become a sustainability guru begins here!
      Jeslin Varghese
      gbri-logo

      Sustainability education should not have any boundaries!

      Register now to get started.

      By creating an account, I declare that I have read and accepted GBRI’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

      Please accept the Terms and Conditions to proceed.
      OR REGISTER WITH
      GBRI is your #1 source for sustainability education with more than 250 courses to choose from!
      gbri-logo

      Welcome back!

      Login to access your sustainability courses, certificates, badges, community and more!
      OR LOGIN WITH